Hong Kong Cinemagic
Version française English version
 Capsule Reviews   English Board   Facebook  
 People
 Movies
 Movie Studios
 Glossary
 Your Settings

HKCine Search
Switch to Google Search
>> Help

 Film directors
 Actors
 Technicians
 Producers

 Comedy
 Drama & Opera

 Shaw Brothers
 Film Industry
 Cultural & Societal

 DVD Tests
 HK Cinema Books
 Where to buy?

 OST & Music
 PDF & E-books
 VIP Guestbook

 Site Map
 Editos Archives
 Staff
 Site History
 Links
 Visitor guestbook
 Aknowledgement
 HKCinemagic 2

Statistics :
11630 Movies
19215 People
1448 Studios
29 Articles
73 Interviews
12 DVD Reviews
32452 Screenshots
3722 Videos
Test DVD : The Duel (Funimation)
DVD Review Page 1
Info
Author(s) : Sylvia Rorem
Date : 14/8/2010
Type(s) : DVD Review
Review
 
 Intext Links  
People :
Chang Cheh
David Chiang Da Wei
Chiu Kang Chien
Chuen Yuen
Ku Feng
Miyaki Yukio
Ti Lung
Tong Gaai
Wong Chung
Wong Ping
Yuen Cheung Yan
Movies :
The Duel
Triangle
Vengeance !
Companies :
Shaw Brothers
Lexic :
Yanggang
 
< Previous
Index


Art is, according to Chang Cheh, “extravagant excess”. To appreciate excess is to appreciate Chang’s 1971 film The Duel. Funimation did right releasing Shaw BrothersThe Duel stateside in August 2010 because it is one of the most excessively beautiful, violent, visceral and romantic tragedies that Chang Cheh ever made. This yanggang flick followed hot on the heels of Chang’s Vengeance! and solidified the Iron Triangle (unbreakable team) of Chang, Ti Lung and David Chiang. Although nowhere near as lean, mean or powerful as Vengeance!, The Duel features the young demi-gods once again battling with knives and axes for their lives and their honor, loving beautiful women, and righting wrongs, all the while knee-deep in dying Shaw stuntmen and gallons of tomato-red blood. The Duel is an over-the-top, operatic masterpiece of tragic, passionate revenge. It is extravagant excess. It is art.

 
The Movie

The tragedy takes place in Chang Cheh’s anachronistic vision of 1930’s Republican China. Writer Chiu Kang Chien’s plot is unnecessarily convoluted but the difficult details are not intrinsic to the core story. Ti Lung stars as Ren Jie, an underworld boss’ happy-go-lucky hoodlum godson with super heroic knife skills and a heart of gold. This sunny Adonis and his lovely sweetheart Hu Die (Wong Ping) lead a romantic life until Ren Jie’s clan is framed by a local warlord for the murder of a competing underworld leader. Moody genius Jian Nan the Rambler (David Chiang) appears with his fan, cigarette holder and symbolic cough to help Ren Jie’s clan fight a gang war manipulated by heartless warlords. Ren Jie soon discovers that although the Rambler is an honorable man, his intentions are double-edged and his presence ambiguous. After the death of Ren Jie’s beloved godfather, devious new boss Gan Wen Bin (played masterfully by Chuen Yuen) tries to destroy Ren Jie and his brother (Ku Feng), and begins to abuse every form of decency in town. The more heinous the crimes committed against Ren Jie and his loved ones, the more the young hero’s vengeful outrage hurtles him down the path of no return. Using his deadly twin knives, he is determined to exterminate Gan, Gan’s men, and everyone else involved, including the enigmatic Rambler, who is both enemy and friend and possibly something more.

In Chang’s fantasy world, Ren Jie’s passion, romanticized by Ti Lung’s superstar looks and boundless energy, is perfectly balanced by Chiang’s small, dark Rambler, an intensely introverted and brainy character. While Ren Jie’s righteous flying fists, legs and knives pulverize crowds of flailing baddies, the Rambler walks coolly through the chaos, monitoring the situation with detached amusement until it’s time to cut loose on the baddies with his crazy knife ability. Ti and Chiang’s famed fight team magic supplies much of the visceral excitement of The Duel. Their fight scenes, choreographed by Tong Gaai and Yuen Cheung Yan, are heated, crowded and emotional. The stars have delightful turbo-abilities that allow them to box and slash their way through scores of groaning baddies who experience little personal pain. This impressionistic mess is heightened by Vengeance! photographer Miyaki Yukio’s sophisticated color contrasts and evocative frame compositions. For example, Ren Jie’s demi-god status is evoked by an almost ritualistic killing in front of his godfather’s altar, and a mustard silk jacket is such a rich focal point against a sea of gray, black and white stunt fighters that after the Rambler changes into a dark suit and tie, the life of the mustard jacket is carried on by Gan’s right hand man (Wong Chung).

 
 

The art may be terrific but the audience wants action, and a dramatic fight between Ti and Chiang was originally anticipated with great excitement. It did not deliver. The duel between Ren Jie and the Rambler is clumsy, badly timed and anti-climactic. However, it is thankfully short and the final act includes a gang fight in the rain with highly pleasing bamboo poles, guns and sloshing mud and blood. The artistic pain reaches its crescendo with Chang’s extended slow motion finale. It is terrifically over the top, and its awkward yet strangely beautiful uber-catharsis captures on a forever-frozen screen Chang Cheh’s love for extravagant excess.

The Duel may possibly be Chang’s most romantic expression of violence and death. He exploits all his cinematic abilities to create a package of passionate artistry and yanggang tragedy. Iron Triangle and Vengeance! fans and lovers of high drama and artistic violence, make sure not to miss this operatic, hot-blooded, beautiful mess.

Warning: Excessive unrealistic, bloody violence.

 

 
dvd specifications

Distributor: Funimation.com/Hong Kong Connection

Region: 1

Languages: Mandarin Mono, English Mono
Subtitles: English

Format: 2:35:1
Run Time: 110 minutes

1 DVD with a handful of mixed-bag trailers

Release Date: August 2010

Price: $19.98

A comparison by Kenneth Woo of this Funimation DVD to a current Region 3 DVD:  To my delight, the Funimation Region 1 DVD is the best release of The Duel, to date.  In terms of picture quality, the blacks seem to be darker, making the reds noticeably more saturated.  The sound is a clean and slightly enhanced original mono soundtrack.  Funimation did not include the foley gaffs in the Region 3 version.  They isolated only the English dub dialogue and remixed it with the enhanced but original soundtrack.

 

 

conclusion

The Funimation DVD is the Celestial Pictures anamorphic 2.35.1 widescreen transfer. The restoration ensures a nice, lush picture quality. The sound nicely balances music, dialogue and effects, and the English subtitles are easily readable and error-free. The “New Zealand” English dubbing is surprisingly decent but the music in the dubbed version is considerably diminished. The preliminary Funimation promotional reel cannot be skipped but can be fast-forwarded on select players. The chapter selection pictures are numerous and small, making selection somewhat difficult but the main menu is simple and easily navigable.

This DVD is a good buy for North American fans.

 
Click to go to The Duel page
 
Page :  1   Top
Previous :
Index

 Advertise with Google AdSense   Submit a review   Contact   FAQ   Terms of use   Disclaimer   Error Report  
copyright ©1998-2013 hkcinemagic.com